MyFitnessPal vs NuJourney: Which Fitness App Is Better in 2025?

If you're looking for a fitness tracking app, you've probably come across MyFitnessPal—it's been around since 2005 and has over 200 million users. But is it still the best choice in 2025?

In this comparison, we'll break down how MyFitnessPal stacks up against NuJourney, a newer all-in-one fitness app that's gaining traction among gym-goers who want more than just calorie counting.

Quick Comparison

Nutrition Tracking: A Close Race

Both apps excel at nutrition tracking—it's MyFitnessPal's bread and butter, after all.

MyFitnessPal has the largest food database in the industry with over 14 million foods. Their barcode scanner is fast and accurate, and the app has years of user-verified entries.

NuJourney has a database of over 1 million foods with barcode scanning. While smaller, it covers most common foods and brands. The key difference is that NuJourney integrates nutrition with your workout data, showing you how your eating affects your training performance.

Winner: Tie — Both get the job done for macro tracking.

Workout Tracking: NuJourney Pulls Ahead

This is where the apps diverge significantly.

MyFitnessPal's workout tracking is basic. You can log exercises and estimated calories burned, but there's no support for:

• Tracking sets, reps, and weight
• Progressive overload analysis
• Custom workout programs
• Rest timers or workout timers

NuJourney was built for gym-goers. You get:

• Complete workout logging with sets, reps, and weight
• Live workout timer with boxing bells (audio cues)
• Progressive overload tracking to see if you're getting stronger
• Custom training programs with periodization
• Rest timer suggestions based on exercise type

If you're serious about strength training, NuJourney gives you the tools MyFitnessPal simply doesn't have.

Winner: NuJourney — Not even close for gym enthusiasts.

Mental Wellness: A Feature MyFitnessPal Doesn't Have

Here's something unique to NuJourney: CBT journaling.

CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) is a proven technique for managing stress, anxiety, and negative thought patterns. NuJourney includes a full 7-step thought record system that helps you:

• Track your mood alongside your workouts
• Identify cognitive distortions (negative thinking patterns)
• Build mental resilience
• See correlations between mental state and physical performance

MyFitnessPal has no mental wellness features whatsoever.

For athletes and fitness enthusiasts who understand that mindset matters, this is a significant advantage.

Winner: NuJourney — MyFitnessPal doesn't compete here.

Social Features & Motivation

MyFitnessPal has a basic social feed and friend system, but engagement is limited. You can share diary entries and cheer friends, but there's no competitive element.

NuJourney takes a gamified approach:

• Aura Points: Earn points for every workout, meal logged, and journal entry
• Levels: Progress through levels as you stay consistent
• Achievements: Unlock badges like "7-Day Streak Warrior" and "Macro Master"
• Gym Leaderboards: Compete with members of your actual gym
• Daily Tasks: Auto-generated challenges to keep you engaged

The gym community feature is particularly powerful—you join your real gym's page and see how you rank against other members weekly and monthly.

Winner: NuJourney — Gamification drives real engagement.

Pricing: NuJourney Costs Less

Let's talk money.

MyFitnessPal Premium: $19.99/month or $79.99/year

• Ad-free experience
• Macro goals by meal
• Food analysis
• Priority support

NuJourney Premium: $12.99/month or $119/year

• 90-day analytics (vs 7 days free)
• Progressive overload tracking
• Macro breakdown insights
• Custom training programs
• Data export

That's $7 less per month for NuJourney, with significantly more features if you're into strength training.

Both offer free tiers, but NuJourney's free tier includes unlimited logging with 7-day analytics, while MyFitnessPal's free tier is heavily ad-supported with limited features.

Winner: NuJourney — More features, lower price.

Who Should Use Each App?

Choose MyFitnessPal if:

• You only care about calorie/macro tracking
• You don't do strength training
• You want the largest possible food database
• You're already invested in the MyFitnessPal ecosystem

Choose NuJourney if:

• You want workout AND nutrition tracking in one app
• You're into strength training or gym workouts
• You want gamification to stay motivated
• Mental wellness matters to you
• You want gym community features
• You want to pay less for more features

The Bottom Line

MyFitnessPal is a solid nutrition tracking app that's been around for nearly 20 years. But it hasn't evolved much for the modern fitness enthusiast who wants comprehensive tracking.

NuJourney represents the next generation of fitness apps—combining workout tracking, nutrition, mental wellness, and social features into one gamified platform. At a lower price point.

If you're currently using multiple apps (one for food, one for workouts, one for journaling), NuJourney consolidates everything into a single, cohesive experience.

Try NuJourney Free

Ready to see the difference? NuJourney offers a 14-day free trial of Premium features, no credit card required.

Start Your Free Trial →

Still have questions? Check out our pricing page or learn more about NuJourney.